NYCALLAMERICAN vs NathanNYC

[+ DiscerningNYC]

Fellas, help me out here. If one had to choose, on what grounds would one make the choice? 
 

https://rentmen.eu/NycAllAmerican

https://rentmen.eu/NathanNYC

[Wanderoz]

I’d choose Nathan & hope he was in a versatile mood!

[+ DiscerningNYC]

25 minutes ago, Wanderoz said:

I’d choose Nathan & hope he was in a versatile mood!

But why…is Nathan more btm? Thnx,

[marylander1940]

1 hour ago, ChelseaWest said:

But why…is Nathan more btm? Thnx,

his ad says versatile top, not versatile bottom.

[MikeH10]

and judging from his twitter, Nathan seems to lean much more top

[DMICS]

I'd pick Nathan, big fan of his content. I'd just make sure he isn't on something before starting a session. 

[+ DiscerningNYC]

Hm…no support for AllAmerican? I’m not looking to date. Personality is icing on the cake…but the cake had better be tasty too. 

[DWnyc]

 

Nathan seems the kinder gentler personality who’s more human and fun.

I’d book NYC A-A for practice every so often on how to hold on to Nathan. Wouldn’t want more time with him after the session ended 😉

 

[NYXboy]

I have been with NYCallamerican and I would give him 11/10 stars. 

He is muscular - but natural looking muscular not working out in the gym every day muscular, intelligent, kind - and BIG everywhere. I am going back for a round 2 no doubt about it. 

 

I have been following Nathans twitter, his pics are amazing but some of his comments have kind of turned me off a little. 

[Wanderoz]

14 hours ago, DMICS said:

I'd pick Nathan, big fan of his content. I'd just make sure he isn't on something before starting a session. 

Any links to see any of his content?

[Colton]

9 hours ago, NYXboy said:

NYCallamerican

Did he have a different name before?  Something referencing California?

[+ DiscerningNYC]

To @Wanderoz “Not on something”…not exactly a compelling endorsement. 
Would be curious to hear meaningful commentary on NYAA. Thanks.

[BrklynNYC]

NYCAA says he doesn't kiss when I reached out to him before so I never pursued. 

Edited March 14, 2024 by MmM

[Brosnan]

NYAA was CaliforniaBoi for a long time. There are several threads about him here. I saw him once pre-Covid & had a nice session. At the time I would have said he was more bottom, but he did top me as well and performed well. I thought he was a nice guy. This reminds me I should try him again, maybe with Nathan in a 3-way & see who comes out on top.

[BenjaminNYC]

I also saw him once as well.  Agree he's a nice guy but can't say things went well.  FWIW

[+ azdr0710]

18 minutes ago, BenjaminNYC said:

I also saw him once as well.  Agree he's a nice guy but can't say things went well.  FWIW

two guys are being discussed in this thread.......which one are you referring to?.......thanks

[MCR]

9 hours ago, MmM said:

NYCAA says he doesn't kiss when I reached out to him before so I never pursued. 

If I remember correctly when I met him we kissed but it obviously wasn't memorable lol

[Walt]

13 hours ago, MmM said:

NYCAA says he doesn't kiss when I reached out to him before so I never pursued. 

I totally believe you -- but his profile does say kissing (which I have previously noted to myself as a positive thing). My head hurts. it's already too hard to evaluate all the choices out there, and then when a provider is not consistent in their self-description....

[BonVivant]

4 hours ago, Walt said:

I totally believe you -- but his profile does say kissing (which I have previously noted to myself as a positive thing). My head hurts. it's already too hard to evaluate all the choices out there, and then when a provider is not consistent in their self-description....

Analysis paralysis. Make a decision and go for it.  Experience it. 

[+ Charlie]

Do you want a date to go to dinner and the opera, or to a bar and an orgy?

[Walt]

4 hours ago, Charlie said:

Do you want a date to go to dinner and the opera, or to a bar and an orgy?

How much kissing do you do at the opera?  😉

[+ Charlie]

11 minutes ago, Walt said:

How much kissing do you do at the opera?  😉

I assume you would only discreetly hold hands.

[dutchal]

On 3/15/2024 at 6:52 PM, Walt said:

How much kissing do you do at the opera?  😉

Depends on how interesting the opera is.

[Strafe13]

On 3/15/2024 at 12:10 AM, Walt said:

I totally believe you -- but his profile does say kissing (which I have previously noted to myself as a positive thing). My head hurts. it's already too hard to evaluate all the choices out there, and then when a provider is not consistent in their self-description....

I meet with All American back when he was California Boi a few years ago (I’ll call him “AA/CB” for short). I was also confused about the kissing, as his ad listed it among his interests back then as well, but like the other poster, he told me that he doesn’t kiss.  So, either AA/CB doesn’t proofread his ad, or he just didn’t want to kiss us and used that as an excuse😝.  
 

Despite the kissing fiasco, I enjoyed the session with AA/CB. I’m a total bottom who needed to get railed, and he did a good job at that (by the time I’d hired him, his ad listed him as only a top, and I believe that’s still the case).  However, he acted really weird when I contacted him shortly after our session, so I haven’t attempted to rehire him.

[DWnyc]

On 3/15/2024 at 4:48 AM, BonVivant said:

Analysis paralysis. Make a decision and go for it.  Experience it. 

You just killed the need for this site …😉