Wow. Much like Boop, this show surprised me. I'm very glad I saw it. I could easily see it again.
I thought the staging was superb. Very creative and immersive. The use of audience members is fun and quite charming. The design of the theater for this event is near perfect. Very few bad seats in this house.
Jonathan Groff blew me away. I don't know how he does this 8 times a week. I suspect he's living a disciplined life, since his name is the only one above the title. He has an understudy, but it seems most people are there to see Jonathan, and he does not disappoint. He really gives them everything he has, including a fun moment in nothing but his underwear. The audience went wild.
He pokes fun at his wetness, and apologizes for the shower the audience and his fellow actors are about to receive. He is a major sweater and spitter. One can only imagine what sex must be like with him (cue the swimming pool).
I have to say, I'm not a fan of the music. I was never a Bobby Darin fan or a Connie Francis fan. I remember Sandra Dee from Gidget, and I remember liking her, thinking she had a cute and perky look. But none of that matters. The story is fascinating, interesting, and told in a very unique and entertaining way. The ancillary performers are all well cast. The music sells itself by default. The band on stage is terrific, and the arrangements are so much fun. You can't help but want to dance or fall in love. Even though Act 2 is slightly more dull and depressing (the guy does die at age 37), the cast ends the show with quite a wallop.
In the end, I am so glad I got to see one of my favorite performers from Glee. I loved Jonathan and Lea Michele in Glee. So glad I got to see them on Broadway being outstanding performers.
On the night I saw the show, the audience was old. The seating area is not fun to navigate for older folk, and the staff are always yelling, "Be careful where you step." I wonder how many young people would be interested in this show? Bobby Darin hit his peak in the 1950's. It was nice to discover the audience didn't sound old. These people were loud and excited.
I had a fabulous aisle seat, thanks to a generous board member, but there was a 350 pound woman seated next to me. Her left arm fully covered my right arm rest, and her left hip took 30% of my seat away. The seats in this theater are terrible, and because of this women, I was very scared of possible leg cramps, given how I had to sit. Luckily, the aisle seat across from me remained empty, so I switched at intermission.