JIMMY TROY

[Roger Smith]

 

Can you guys help me understand this one?  JimmyTroy gets universal praise here, but I'm skeptical looking at his profile.

I have a regular guy who I see for BFE, and, if you ask me, he's hands-down the best BFE in NYC.  I'm all about a vers piggy bareback connection, and a guy who's genuinely invested in the moment and in me, regardless of how attractive he thinks I am.  But like anybody, I love a little variety, a little spice, once in a while.  So maybe 1 time in 5 I'll try somebody new.  I always go back home to my regular guy, but I love to sample.  

I do tend to shy away from the super extreme fitness guys, no matter how perfect their aesthetics are.  They tend to be primarily interested in their own aesthetics, rather than any client.  And they tend to think their body aesthetics are an adequate stand-in for any connection/piggery.  Add "straight identifying" to the mix, and my skepticism grows.  Add "safe only" to the mix, and it's all but a deal breaker. 

But can all these testimonials be wrong?  I'm genuinely dying to understand this one.  And I can only imagine his price tag makes it a high stakes roll of the dice. 

Can anybody share details to make me understand?  DM is okay, if it's inappropriate for public sharing.  

[Niceguyfinishedlast]

Jimmy Troy is the real deal. He is a sweet young man, articulate, and not egotistical or into himself in the least. He is a phenomenal kisser and he is amazing in bed. His body is perfect and hard as a rock. Can’t recommend him highly enough. Rate is four. Hope this helps. 

[InterestingGuy]

If you want to see him “in action”, he’s done many porn videos - just google “Jimmy Troy”… and if you want to hear him speak and talk about what he likes, you can watch a brief interview with him in the beginning of his porn scene with Justin Matthew’s from 2021. 

[danteig]

1 hour ago, InterestingGuy said:

If you want to see him “in action”, he’s done many porn videos - just google “Jimmy Troy”… and if you want to hear him speak and talk about what he likes, you can watch a brief interview with him in the beginning of his porn scene with Justin Matthew’s from 2021. 

Quite honestly it’s a huge turn on to see a straight dude (I have no doubt that he in fact is straight) enjoying dick so much. 

[Peter Eater]

16 hours ago, danteig said:

Quite honestly it’s a huge turn on to see a straight dude (I have no doubt that he in fact is straight) enjoying dick so much. 

That’s because he’s not, in fact, straight. Bi at the very least. I have it on good authority that straight men don’t enjoy dick so much.

[Colton]

Profile says he is safe only.  Surprising nowadays.

[pubic_assistance]

On 7/30/2026 at 10:04 AM, Peter Eater said:

I have it on good authority that straight men don’t enjoy dick so much

You need to get out more in the real world. THAT isn't even remotely true.

[natmas02]

He's great. I stopped going to Adonis in NYC a while ago (and I think they only do their once a month nude parties now) - he was always super friendly and generous with his time if you treat him with respect. I was one of his many regulars but he always makes time to talk and chat with you. His body is incredibly shredded. 

[Peter Eater]

16 hours ago, pubic_assistance said:

You need to get out more in the real world. THAT isn't even remotely true.

Bi at the very least.

[pubic_assistance]

9 minutes ago, Peter Eater said:

Bi at the very least.

I think a LOT of gays don't understand that just because you can "get off" with a man, you don't suddenly become gay.

The sexual identity of a person is their OWN, and generally based on their romantic connections, more than their sexual reality. There are LOADS of married "straight" men out there who occasionally get a taste for a little mano-a-mano action...then go home to the wife and kids. Same way there are lots of male escorts who have a girlfriend waiting at home for him, after hes done fucking some old-fat-queen who he met while dancing at a strip joint. 

YES. Technically is you can stay hard while fucking a dude up the ass, your bisexuality is pretty much fully engaged. BUT the IDENTITY that this person uses, is not ours to call. THAT is where this always gets confusing. 

The gays all seem to have no problem calling a dude-in-a-dress "she/her" Even when its really obvious its still a dude. BUT they always want to force their own identity observations on men who are sexually fluid, and romantically heterosexual.

Edited Saturday at 01:42 PM by pubic_assistance
spelling

[Peter Eater]

10 minutes ago, pubic_assistance said:

I think a LOT of gays don't understand that just because you can "get off" with a man, you don't suddenly become gay.

The sexual identity of a person is their OWN, and generally based on their romantic connections, more than their sexual reality. There are LOADS of married "straight" men out there who occasionally get a taste for a little mano-a-mano action...then go home to the wife and kids. Same way there are lots of male escorts who have a girlfriend waiting at home for him, after hes done fucking some old-fat-queen who he met while dancing at a strip joint. 

YES. Technically is you can stay hard while fucking a dude up the ass, your bisexuality is pretty much fully engaged. BUT the IDENTITY that this person uses, is not ours to call. THAT is where this always gets confusing. 

The gays all seem to have no problem calling a dude-in-a-dress "she/her" Even when its really obvious its still a dude. BUT they always want to force their own identity observations on men who are sexually fluid, and romantically heterosexual.

I certainly understand your defensiveness, but whether or not one self-identifies as bi is irrelevant to the fact of being bi - which is the case if you’re regularly having sex with women and men, paid or free. 

[pubic_assistance]

3 hours ago, Peter Eater said:

I certainly understand your defensiveness,

DO you ? Because I have nothing to "defend". I openly admit that I am bisexual and when I was younger and dating a guy, I openly identified as gay. 

I was discussing the habit of gay men to quickly judge someone's sexual identity based on who they let suck their dick, with no regard to how someone identifies in his/her romantic life.  Anyway...back to Jimmy Troy. He does list "straight" on his profile. So considering the number of times he takes it up the ass on film and with customers, I am going to assume he is saving up for his future which includes a wife, picket fence, kids and a golden retriever. Or maybe it just sounds hotter and it's all marketing. Only Jimmy knows. But it's his own to decide.

[diehard_002]

He was at Spunk this past Thursday. Looking good as ever and quite the gold standard in this business. There is a certain melancholic sincerity in his eyes which makes me want to hug him deeply each time i see him.

Edited Saturday at 06:51 PM by diehard_002

[+ BOZO T CLOWN]

1 minute ago, diehard_002 said:

He was at Spunk this past Thursday. Looking good as ever and quite the gold standard in this business. There is a certain melancholic something about him which makes me want to hug him deeply each time i see him.

And he was at Red Eye at the @Buff Daddy event on Friday night. Jimmy seems to get more muscular each time Bozo sees him, yet he is able to keep his narrow, tapered waist and six-pack abs. Kudos to him for the dedication and hard work  he puts in regularly to maintain that rock-hard, chiseled physique.

Jimmy self-identifies as straight. He has a long-time girlfriend that he will speak about only if asked.
It would probably be much better for business if he would lie and tell people he was gay. He doesn't. His honesty speaks volumes about his integrity. He's a class act.

BTC
🤡

[Peter Eater]

20 hours ago, pubic_assistance said:

I was discussing the habit of gay men to quickly judge someone's sexual identity based on who they let suck their dick,

No, we were discussing it based on them doing the sucking of dick - being the sucker, not the suckee - in which case they are at the very least bi. Their self-identification is irrelevant.

Edited yesterday at 01:52 PM by Peter Eater

[Whatsupandstuff]

1 hour ago, Peter Eater said:

No, we were discussing it based on them doing the sucking of dick - being the sucker, not the suckee - in which case they are at the very least bi. Their self-identification is irrelevant.

and he seems to enjoy it immensely 

[pubic_assistance]

On 8/2/2026 at 9:50 AM, Peter Eater said:

Their self-identification is irrelevant.

Would you say the same about trans people ? 

It's not unusual for the gays to be super defensive of using the "proper pronouns" to defend the chosen identity of trans people, while being completely dismissive of the chosen sexual identity of men who identify as gay, but have bisexual tendencies. YES. Technically if you're sexually attracted to BOTH men and women, you are definitely bisexual. BUT like transexuals, the modern social norm is to RESPECT how a person wants to be identified him/her self. If Jimmy has a romantic partner who is a woman, and he therefore chooses to identify as "straight" because of that fact, then that's up to him.

Edited 4 hours ago by pubic_assistance
grammar

[PileDriver]

once again pubic_assitance speaks the truth...get over it already!!! sexuality is just not simple and stop trying to make it that...especially on a site that caters to gays...the world is a beautiful place full of diversity....enjoy it and just stop the nit-picking and categorizing and handwringing over what is someone's confident and beautiful choice to embrace the worlds and its diversity, ugh..emough

[Peter Eater]

3 hours ago, pubic_assistance said:

Would you say the same about trans people

 

3 hours ago, pubic_assistance said:

like transexuals, the modern social norm is

You really need to learn the difference between transgender and transsexual, and why many consider transsexual to be outdated and even offensive. 
Also, spelling.

https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/transgender-vs-transexual#is-transsexual-offensive

[Peter Eater]

3 hours ago, PileDriver said:

once again pubic_assitance speaks the truth...get over it already!!! sexuality is just not simple and stop trying to make it that...especially on a site that caters to gays...the world is a beautiful place full of diversity....enjoy it and just stop the nit-picking and categorizing and handwringing over what is someone's confident and beautiful choice to embrace the worlds and its diversity, ugh..emough

Sucking dick is what many  heterosexual women and gay and bisexual men like to do. As Merriam Webster puts it, straight is a vernacular synonym for heterosexual, meaning “of, relating to, or involving sexual activity between individuals of the opposite sex.”

Jimmy Troy can identify as whatever he wants. (For all we know, he identifies as straight because there is benefit from the designation in the social hierarchy.) But, whatever the case, I don’t need to concur, and there is nothing disrespectful about recognizing that he is, in fact, bisexual, if indeed he “enjoys sucking dick so much.” 

[PileDriver]

ohhh...not as stupid as you think...check your language and assumptions...such  hatred is normally a sign of self hatred...so blees you and will pray for your redemption...

[Roger Smith]

But does he require condoms for anal?

Seems a more important question than any of the above, and I couldn’t find an answer.