How to know when a comment is a review?

[xyz48B]

Instead of (purposefully!) misinterpreting what @Charlie said, perhaps reflect upon your own words to a fellow forum member earlier this week:

 

It sounds like you have also made up your mind on this topic. ??‍♂️

Cute.

 

I haven’t made up my mind. I’m asking for clarification.

 

A rule that is unclear is hard to enforce. “No reviews” when there’s no clear guidance about what constitutes a review is an unhelpful rule. There’s an entire subjection on this forum that could be considered reviewettes, if you will. It seems like there are varying opinions about what makes for a “review.”

 

To be clear, I have no intention of reviewing or otherwise publicly saying anything about any experience I have with a provider on this forum again after my last attempt to do so was attacked because some here liked the escort in question and I had the temerity to speak somehow unfavorably about him. It is clear some member’s opinions are valued more than others here. It is what it is. But I will push for clarity if I see there isn’t any.

 

So to circle round to the front, a review, which is not allowed in this particular forum but welcome on an unaffiliated site, is any negative comment about an escort. All praise is welcome. More or less, unless you want to talk about your 5-star experience, don’t share here. See your way to Daddy’s. I don’t know why that’s so hard to admit...Is it because we don’t want to call a thing a thing?

[xyz48B]

But Viscount @FrankR – thanks for moderating and attempting to silence me.

[xyz48B]

https://www.companyofmen.org/threads/411-daniel-brazilian-awesome-body.154302/

 

To me, this thread (only used as an example) is filled with “reviews.” They just happen to be positive.

[Guy Fawkes]

It was brought in by Hooboy.

 

I feel that any clear-cut definition would be impossible. The rule of No Reviews was brought in, as I recall the history, after the crackdown on Rentboy; the rule is intended to protect the site from unwelcome attention by the authorities.

 

I believe it’s useful and allowed to say things like “I’m a total bottom and he made me very happy” or “I’m a total top and we were very compatible”. I think that details can better be conveyed in private messages.

[+ Charlie]

It was brought in by Hooboy.

Hooboy believed that if someone hired a named escort and wished to report details of what had happened during their meeting, positive or negative, it should be submitted for oversight as a review, and not simply discussed as scuttlebutt on the message board. He thought the escort had a right to know what was said about him by a client, and to respond to it.

[xyz48B]

Hooboy believed that if someone hired a named escort and wished to report details of what had happened during their meeting, positive or negative, it should be submitted for oversight as a review, and not simply discussed as scuttlebutt on the message board. He thought the escort had a right to know what was said about him by a client, and to respond to it.

Sounds like a good principle if the escort is part of the forum. There are many escorts who are also not reviewed on Daddy’s – whether because someone won’t review them or some other reason. Question – how is an escort given opportunity to respond on Daddy’s? Are they somehow contacted before the review goes live? What’s to stop an escort from responding here to reviews if they can respond to Daddy’s unaffiliated* site?

 

*How unaffiliated is Daddy’s and this forum? I have long been under the operating assumption they were separate but related entities. Am I wrong?

[MscleLovr]

You have so many questions @xyz48B on how the site operates. Wouldn’t it be better for you to contact the Administrator/s direct and ask them?

[xyz48B]

You have so many questions @xyz48B on how the site operates. Wouldn’t it be better for you to contact the Administrator/s direct and ask them?

It seems so many guys here already know everything. And they love to impart their wisdom. Let’s give ‘em a chance to shine!

[+ 7829V]

If I “give” stars ⭐️ to the masseur. Would that be considered a review? Or maybe a check list with check marks?

Something like this:

 

✔️ massage table

❌ music

✔️ profesional massage cream

 

masseur A ⭐️⭐️ ⭐️ out of 5

[Epigonos]

This question comes up periodically. To be perfectly honest the rules regarding what can and what cannot be said about escorts in reviews is vague. Thus Daddy is able to decide whether or not the review is too explicit or not and whether or not to post it. I used to write reviews when ever I met with a new escorts. However, because of the current limits on what can and what cannot be stated in a review I haven't written one in several years. As some of you, I'm sure, have noticed if I want to say something about an escort meeting I've had I simply state here that we got together and that I enjoyed his company and recommend him. I then add if anyone wants additional information he should PM me and I will answer any questions he may have. This system has work to my satisfaction and I will continue the practice.

Edited October 7, 2020 by Epigonos