NYCALLAMERICAN vs NathanNYC

[+ DiscerningNYC]

Apologies to @DWnyc and @BonVivant, but my budget for the “hobby”’to which this site relates…is not unlimited. Caveat emptor is as valid as ever

[BananaBagel]

On 3/13/2024 at 2:45 PM, ManattanDude said:

Fellas, help me out here. If one had to choose, on what grounds would one make the choice? 
 

https://rentmen.eu/NycAllAmerican

https://rentmen.eu/NathanNYC

Hey did you end up meeting with one of them or maybe treated yourself to both?

[+ burtjohn]

I've seen both, and I'd vote for Nathan. AA was very nice, mostly a top, kissed but not enthusiastically, and rushed a bit. Nathan took his time and really aimed to please.

[KevinFL]

On 3/18/2024 at 12:57 PM, Strafe13 said:

I meet with All American back when he was California Boi a few years ago (I’ll call him “AA/CB” for short). I was also confused about the kissing, as his ad listed it among his interests back then as well, but like the other poster, he told me that he doesn’t kiss.  So, either AA/CB doesn’t proofread his ad, or he just didn’t want to kiss us and used that as an excuse😝.  
 

Despite the kissing fiasco, I enjoyed the session with AA/CB. I’m a total bottom who needed to get railed, and he did a good job at that (by the time I’d hired him, his ad listed him as only a top, and I believe that’s still the case).  However, he acted really weird when I contacted him shortly after our session, so I haven’t attempted to rehire him.

Yes I met with "California Boi" pre-covid also and he's definitely YMMV and his place was filthy and he was an hour late for the meeting. I just remember sitting in the sun waiting for him to finally arrive at his place and it was far from memorable once he arrived. He avoided kissing also and it was actually a day that I remembered to brush my teeth too. 🤣 His loss. 

[+ Gar1eth]

I'm can't pick either if  AA doesn't kiss-that's a no go no matter how great his physique is. 
 

And Nathan now advertises as only a 'top'. So another no go. 

[BaronArtz]

Both guys are EWWWWWW to me.  For various reasons.

I live in NYC and am happy to have a core group of masseurs/escorts that treat me VERY well.  I only venture outside if I am blown away by the opportunity.  In these cases, I am most definitely NOT.

[+ nycman]

On 3/16/2024 at 4:04 AM, Charlie said:

I assume you would only discreetly hold hands.

As if opera wasn’t boring enough…..

grin

[DMICS]

4 hours ago, BaronArtz said:

Both guys are EWWWWWW to me.  For various reasons.

Care to breakdown those reasons? I'm curious. 

[BrklynNYC]

I wish Nathan would at least trim his beard. 😣

[BaronArtz]

7 minutes ago, MmM said:

I wish Nathan would at least trim his beard. 😣

I agree with that!  The combo of an untrimmed beard and an entirely natural untrimmed bush really turns me off.  But I shouldn't be so judgmental ... what is abhorrent to me probably is  attractive to someone else.

Edited April 13 by BaronArtz

[NYC_BTM_321]

On 3/14/2024 at 9:11 AM, Colton said:

Did he have a different name before?  Something referencing California?

He did.  Like Californiaboy

[NYC_BTM_321]

On 3/13/2024 at 10:40 PM, DiscerningNYC said:

Hm…no support for AllAmerican? I’m not looking to date. Personality is icing on the cake…but the cake had better be tasty too. 

Just seeing this - I've hired AA a few times.   he's big.  everywhere.  hands, feet, cock, muscles.  massive shooter.   was my pleasure to spoil him.  I'd told him I would not do anything if he asked.  and he never asked.  told me what needed to be done.🙈

[EastbayMike]

On 4/13/2025 at 6:11 AM, BaronArtz said:

I agree with that!  The combo of an untrimmed beard and an entirely natural untrimmed bush really turns me off.  But I shouldn't be so judgmental ... what is abhorrent to me probably is  attractive to someone else.

You are correct. Very attractive to this sometime else!

[+ DiscerningNYC]

On 9/18/2024 at 2:44 PM, BananaBagel said:

Hey did you end up meeting with one of them or maybe treated yourself to both?

Booked with neither of them. Took the massage route. Alas.

[pubic_assistance]

On 4/13/2025 at 9:11 AM, BaronArtz said:

The combo of an untrimmed beard and an entirely natural untrimmed bush really turns me off.  But I shouldn't be so judgmental ... what is abhorrent to me probably is  attractive to someone else.

Absolutely.

Nothing more disgusting to me than shaved pubes.

Love a man who shows up with what God gave him.

[NYC_BTM_321]

On 3/18/2024 at 12:57 PM, Strafe13 said:

I meet with All American back when he was California Boi a few years ago (I’ll call him “AA/CB” for short). I was also confused about the kissing, as his ad listed it among his interests back then as well, but like the other poster, he told me that he doesn’t kiss.  So, either AA/CB doesn’t proofread his ad, or he just didn’t want to kiss us and used that as an excuse😝.  
 

Despite the kissing fiasco, I enjoyed the session with AA/CB. I’m a total bottom who needed to get railed, and he did a good job at that (by the time I’d hired him, his ad listed him as only a top, and I believe that’s still the case).  However, he acted really weird when I contacted him shortly after our session, so I haven’t attempted to rehire him.

i have found him to be a beast but that's what I have requested.   Repeat client here as well.  Never a complaint