MuscleDaddyJames in Phoenix - caveat emptor

[LA90046]

I would be a bit disappointed if I was expecting the guy on the left but it was the guy on the right who showed up.

https://rent.men/MuscleDaddyJames

 

[builder boy]

Which one is it 

[JoeHonolulu]

🤯

[RickRob]

Hard to believe that this provider is still out there. He showed up many years ago at my downtown hotel absurdly dressed for a man of his age. Regret not pulling the plug on the encounter right then. I have never seen the photo on the left and he was not using it to advertise then. 

[+ Gar1eth]

3 hours ago, LA90046 said:

I would be a bit disappointed if I was expecting the guy on the left but it was the guy on the right who showed up.

https://rent.men/MuscleDaddyJames

 

Well I'd much prefer the left.  But I'd still let the guy on the right eat cookies in my bed-although not as many as the guy on the left.

 

It's a tough call. I've had providers before who looked worse than that in comparison to these two pictures. One I remember specifically. We met up at a Motel 6 or someplace similar as I couldn't host. In his pictures he looked leanly athletic. I  probably should have canceled when he turned up 20 or so pounds heavier-and not due to muscle (I barely recognized him as his face was so much fuller). But I didn't.

It's interesting. This guy says in his ad copy that his tallywacker is 9". But on his listed stats he's 8". So he's lost an inch.  

[Tandy Newton]

Some of the pictures, his iPhone is distorted and the belly buttons don't match. The actual profile picture does match, but looks like too much bait and switch.

[+ purplekow]

If he is a competitive body builder, it is possible that both pictures are accurate one when he is in contest shape and the other when he is not.  On the other hand, I vote for photoshop of the photo on the left. 

[AntSuck]

Hello everyone.  I just made this account to ask about James.  He’ll be traveling to my city, and he’s asking for a 50% deposit.  It sucks because I love muscle men and I think he’s stunning, but I know deposits are a red flag here and I don’t like them myself.

Does anyone have any recent experience to add about James?

[rojjodc]

On 8/23/2026 at 9:39 AM, AntSuck said:

Hello everyone.  I just made this account to ask about James.  He’ll be traveling to my city, and he’s asking for a 50% deposit.  It sucks because I love muscle men and I think he’s stunning, but I know deposits are a red flag here and I don’t like them myself.

Does anyone have any recent experience to add about James?

Well, did you see him and if you did, is he still as muscular as his pictures?  Although he seems legit, I guess he is asking to determine if prearranged bookings would pay for trip.  My concern with any deposit would be whether they would be promptly refunded if the trip and/or session was canceled.

[AntSuck]

He hasn’t come to my city yet, but I’m going to pass on seeing him.

[+ azdr0710]

in the left picture, take a look at the curtains next to his left shoulder and left waistline......strangely warped, eh??!!......I'm no photo manipulation expert, but have learned the easy things to look for, including strangely formed hands/fingers and the background warps.....and check out the upper right corner of the picture frame

Edited September 11 by azdr0710

[rvwnsd]

Those pictures were dated in 2019 when I hired him.

[studchaser]

On 8/23/2026 at 9:39 AM, AntSuck said:

Hello everyone.  I just made this account to ask about James.  He’ll be traveling to my city, and he’s asking for a 50% deposit.  It sucks because I love muscle men and I think he’s stunning, but I know deposits are a red flag here and I don’t like them myself.

Does anyone have any recent experience to add about James?

Whats your town??? Are the pickings slim??

[AntSuck]

I’m in the Midwest.  The pickings are kind of slim, but I’m still ok without seeing him.

[builder boy]

I would never do a 50 percent deposit 

[studchaser]

On 9/14/2026 at 4:33 PM, AntSuck said:

I’m in the Midwest.  The pickings are kind of slim, but I’m still ok without seeing him.

50 percent deposits are a bit high. Deposits in general shouldn't rule anyone out though. I know this may shock some ppl on here but there are alot of ppl who ppse as clients and waste guys time. They ask for pics, vids etc and even make dates and then ghost. In general id say 100 dollars for a 2/3 hour visit can be appropriate with someone who seems trustworthy who you are motivated to meet. Usecyour discretion and trust your intuition.

[rojjodc]

4 hours ago, studchaser said:

50 percent deposits are a bit high. Deposits in general shouldn't rule anyone out though. I know this may shock some ppl on here but there are alot of ppl who ppse as clients and waste guys time. They ask for pics, vids etc and even make dates and then ghost. In general id say 100 dollars for a 2/3 hour visit can be appropriate with someone who seems trustworthy who you are motivated to meet. Usecyour discretion and trust your intuition.

The concern with asking for a deposit when visiting a smaller metro is whether the provider will promptly refund if he decides to not come because he decides he does not have enough business.   I think it is risky unless the provider has been the business consistently AND has been visiting the city on regular basis.    I still wouldn't pay a deposit and would wait until the provider actually is in the city.  I would suspect or hope that the provider could see a few extras clients even if he may be fully booked -- the provider might even possibly decide extra days.