New pizza sensation: 'Mikey Marinara'

[Ali Gator]

Has anybody been following this pizza guy on social media ? He's from Long Island, very sexy, a little on the 'socially  awkward' side, has a big social media following.  However, taking advantage of his gay following, he launched an OF a few months ago but the criticism has been it's very expensive $20/m and just shirtless pics. Another subscriber said he charged him $50 extra for 'explicit pictures' which were him in boxer shorts with 'slight shaft' showing  - the same photos he shared on IG. Hmmmm. When the subscriber said he was disappointed, Mikey responded he'd share more explicit for another $70, but wouldn't confirm if they'd be full frontal. Another subscriber said he wanted to charge him $45 extra for an ass pic (he didn't pay). 

Sounds like he's not being too kind or generous to his gay following. 

Anything to share here on Mikey ? 

OnlyFans

ONLYFANS.COM

---

OnlyFans is the social platform revolutionizing creator and fan connections. The site is inclusive of artists and content creators from all genres and allows them to monetize...

 

[Anthony]

Very happy I came across this. He works less than 30 minutes from me. I'm so tempted to visit the pizzeria to see him. Any tips on asking for anything private knowing that he already does OF and is opening up. He also uses his real name which is bold! Maybe I might get to taste the special sauce 😏 

[wsc]

Very handsome, sexy man. I just wish he would knead me.

[+ azdr0710]

ever-reliable LPSG had/has a page on him, but it's now closed (by his request??) and any pictures that may've been on it have been scrubbed.......

https://www.lpsg.com/threads/mikey-marinara-michael-maccarrone.11750181/

[BonVivant]

He's handsome and cute. I'd definitely eat his 🍕

[+ Gar1eth]

He's really handsome. But I'm not usually into straight guys pandering to us. I remember back years ago before Nick Jonas was married when he used to give vague signals that he might be bi-curious. I'm probably more (minuscully) straight-curious than Nick ever was bi. But I don't intend to do anything about it. 
 

 

[Ali Gator]

On 5/30/2025 at 7:59 PM, Anthony said:

Very happy I came across this. He works less than 30 minutes from me. I'm so tempted to visit the pizzeria to see him. Any tips on asking for anything private knowing that he already does OF and is opening up. He also uses his real name which is bold! Maybe I might get to taste the special sauce 😏 

Well, it's been nearly a month...have you 'had a pizza' yet ? Do tell !

Is he as cute as he is on Insta ? 

[Ali Gator]

On 5/31/2025 at 6:02 PM, azdr0710 said:

ever-reliable LPSG had/has a page on him, but it's now closed (by his request??) and any pictures that may've been on it have been scrubbed.......

https://www.lpsg.com/threads/mikey-marinara-michael-maccarrone.11750181/

The consensus in that discussion seems to be his OF is a waste of $$$.  He'll send you pcitures of his ass, and that's it. No dick pics. Some suspect he may be 'small' so he doesn't want pics of his dick out there.

[Anthony]

On 6/22/2025 at 11:22 AM, Ali Gator said:

Well, it's been nearly a month...have you 'had a pizza' yet ? Do tell !

Is he as cute as he is on Insta ? 

Haven't been there yet. Was planning to go but I wanted some advice first before I make the first move. Planning to tip him nicely! 

[+ Gar1eth]

9 hours ago, Anthony said:

Haven't been there yet. Was planning to go but I wanted some advice first before I make the first move. Planning to tip him nicely! 

So will you be giving him 'just the tip'?

[Anthony]

5 hours ago, Gar1eth said:

So will you be giving him 'just the tip'?

Depends if I judge he deserves it or not 

[Ali Gator]

On 6/24/2025 at 1:47 AM, Anthony said:

Haven't been there yet. Was planning to go but I wanted some advice first before I make the first move. Planning to tip him nicely! 

What's the advice that you're seeking ? 

[Anthony]

On 6/25/2025 at 7:51 AM, Ali Gator said:

What's the advice that you're seeking ? 

I want to taste his secret sauce. How do I go about and ask him that? 

[Ali Gator]

4 minutes ago, Anthony said:

I want to taste his secret sauce. How do I go about and ask him that? 

Slide into his DM. 

[Anthony]

23 hours ago, Ali Gator said:

Slide into his DM. 

How do I ask him? 

[Ali Gator]

Here's a picture he posted on his social media this morning. He was at a bonfire last night. It looks like he's shaving / trimming his chest hair - I wish he wouldn't. Nice nipples on him ! 

 

[Lewis H]

He just posted a special of $10 a month to sub, but after seeing all the scammy tactics written about him, I'm not inclined to give him a dime. Although he has now uploaded 3 more videos...but if the first one was just a handstand, hell, I've seen that on his other socials.

[Ali Gator]

He's been sharing 'how to make pizza' on his socials, too. This guy has proven to be a disappointment. It's too bad - he's sexy! 

[qado]

Has anyone managed to find any of his OF content?

[+ Gar1eth]

On 8/10/2025 at 3:12 PM, Ali Gator said:

This guy has proven to be a disappointment

Why a disappointment? 

[+ purplekow]

First of all. Mikey Marinara when his real name is Macarrone.  Why not just change that to Macaroni.  Second, he is just about an average 20 something Italo American from Long Island.  My cousins and I looked way hotter than he when we were in our twenties.  And his body is a bit on the skinny side considering the popularity of weight lifting on Long Island.  I hope his pizza is better than that.

As to how to ask if he does more in private, i would go with the standard:  "I would really like some hot Italian sausage and by the way can you put some on on pizza as well."   If he is inclined to give you a slice, he will pick up on that.  

[BSR]

5 hours ago, purplekow said:

First of all. Mikey Marinara when his real name is Macarrone.  Why not just change that to Macaroni.  Second, he is just about an average 20 something Italo American from Long Island.  My cousins and I looked way hotter than he when we were in our twenties.  And his body is a bit on the skinny side considering the popularity of weight lifting on Long Island.  I hope his pizza is better than that.

As to how to ask if he does more in private, i would go with the standard:  "I would really like some hot Italian sausage and by the way can you put some on on pizza as well."   If he is inclined to give you a slice, he will pick up on that.  

I think he’s super-cute, something about him just tickles my ivories.  That said, his OF sounds like an absolute waste — 20 bucks for a few shirtless pics??  Lighting $20 with a match to burn for heat would be a wiser use of my money.

Edited yesterday at 06:21 AM by BSR
Wording

[ShortCutie7]

I had never heard of him or seen him until this thread, but he looks hot to me! Reminds me of a sexy guy who posts on TikTok who works in a sub shop or something (Google was no help in finding him lol).