I'm remembering now a classic: Score 10 with Ryan Idol.
Eric Stone (as "Eric") and Craig Slater (as "Coach").
Slater kept his baseball cap on the whole damned time; Rick & Dave's Excellent Porn Reviews said "What is he hiding under there? Antennae?".
He convinced Stone that what Stone needed right then was a massage.
Slater also, just before plunging into rubbing his ass, poured oil over Stone's butthole like syrup on pancakes. Awesome.
https://store.falconstudios.com/products/score-10-scene-1
First nominee:
Here's Finch93, who is actually sexier than Wavey Davey (and has a better butt), but a little more annoying. He keeps weaving toward and away from the camera, and talks like he really thinks he's smart.