In a moment of weakness I reached out today and got an appointment with Kevin. I was quite surprised - went into it with some trepidation, but it worked out well. He was on time, very pleasant, not overly chatty and actually went over the agreed time. Massage was just a little better than average, based on my experience - really was full body. Not quite as ripped as in the pics on his profile, but it is him and he looks younger than the pics would indicate. Walked away from our session happy, though I do think he is straight. My impression is that he listed the crazy $ amount quoted above in one specific location where he could get it. He indicated he would like to see me again, so I think he plans to stick around NYC and his rates have been updated to reflect the NYC market. He also plans to travel so if you enjoy traveling masseurs and his type, keep an eye out.
I think I may repeat when next I feel like a bit of pampering - got a good vibe from him. As always, YMMV and maybe somebody else can chime in with their experience...