Eli / Elicarmelo in NYC

[Brooklyntiger]

Anyone with any experience?

https://www.masseurfinder.com/massage-therapists/51732/
 

Elicarmelo - Male Masseur, Gay massage in Manhattan, NY | RentMasseur

RENTMASSEUR.COM

---

Gay Masseur Elicarmelo in Manhattan, NY offering a wide range of massages ⭐ experienced in therapeutic...

 

[+ EVdude]

Was asked about in the Long Island thread  a few weeks back when he was in Patchogue NY. No response then. Hope one here soon! 

[Isik1476]

He's very handsome, looks just like his pictures, and very friendly. Seems straight — he remained clothed for the massage and there was a towel for draping on the table that I wound up getting under because I couldn't tell whether it was there for my comfort or his. It wound up being a purely therapeutic massage, and a rare great one at that, so I'm not complaining — but next time I'll be more explicit and ask if he also does sensual/erotic, especially for $220/hr. 

[MattWise2003]

That rate seems high for purely therapeutic session. 

[+ WestGuy]

On 12/2/2025 at 12:02 AM, MattWise2003 said:

That rate seems high for purely therapeutic session. 

Agree and he should not advertise for sensual massage and include shirtless pics in his ad if he is going to only offer therapeutic massage while fully clothed. Lots of other choices at that price point that deliver exceptional therapeutic/erotic sessions.

[massagefan320]

He was fully clothed for me too, but I wasn't draped.  It was a great massage, and he is adorable, but I agree he shouldn't advertise with shirtless photos.

[allyouknow]

offers sensual - shows a lot of skin and suggestive pics - he is baiting.  not cool 

[SubNYCTwink]

I saw him as well and do very much recommend as long as you go in with the correct intentions. He is very skilled at massage and that aspect was amazing. Mine was also very sensual with a lot of fun mutual touch, he stayed clothed but I was undraped. No HE but lots of fun sensual touch throughout, and overall very handsome and a really sweet guy

[massagefan320]

1 hour ago, SubNYCTwink said:

I saw him as well and do very much recommend as long as you go in with the correct intentions. He is very skilled at massage and that aspect was amazing. Mine was also very sensual with a lot of fun mutual touch, he stayed clothed but I was undraped. No HE but lots of fun sensual touch throughout, and overall very handsome and a really sweet guy

Normally my rule is if the masseur doesn't undress, I assume he doesn't want to be touched, so I didn't.  I remember my massage being very sensual, so I was confused why he didn't disrobe, even at the end.

[SubNYCTwink]

 

On 12/9/2025 at 9:47 AM, massagefan320 said:

Normally my rule is if the masseur doesn't undress, I assume he doesn't want to be touched, so I didn't.  I remember my massage being very sensual, so I was confused why he didn't disrobe, even at the end.

It’s always YMMV, but I definitely haven’t found that to be the case. Some of my fave MT is when the masseur is still clothed. The process of discovery can be very fun haha. You have to use your people skills of course and listen to the situation. You can tell if someone wants to be touched or not pretty quickly and you have to follow along with that. He was definitely encouraging and leaning into me touching him but he did stay robed. We talked after and he said he’s cool with sensual etc but just likes to keep it quasi-professional which im very OK with. Planning on repeating sometime soon.

[massagefan320]

3 hours ago, SubNYCTwink said:

 

It’s always YMMV, but I definitely haven’t found that to be the case. Some of my fave MT is when the masseur is still clothed. The process of discovery can be very fun haha. You have to use your people skills of course and listen to the situation. You can tell if someone wants to be touched or not pretty quickly and you have to follow along with that. He was definitely encouraging and leaning into me touching him but he did stay robed. We talked after and he said he’s cool with sensual etc but just likes to keep it quasi-professional which im very OK with. Planning on repeating sometime soon.

Normally, the masseur is at least shirtless, so I don't encounter this situation often.  I didn't get the sense for me that he wanted me touching him, which is fine.  I appreciate he wants to keep it professional.  Other guys are much more explicit that they are ok with me touching them, etc.  The issue is, for what he is charging, there are other options in NYC that charge similar prices for erotic massages that are unambiguous in their allowances of how far to go.  I have to draw the line on pricing somewhere.  If he was the only option in a remote city, I would regularly see him.  It was a great massage otherwise.   

Edited December 11, 2025 by massagefan320

[Tonyfuntime]

Recently got a massage from him in Miami. 

- Looks exactly like his pics. Cute, handsome, muscular, nice body (more lean type but not bulky). He's also very responsive during texts, accomodating with scheduling, and friendly when we met. 

- Rate is 220/ hour at his place. 

- Decent (B+/ A-) massage skill with good strokes. His touches feel quite sensual at "sensual" places on the body but not erotic or sexually playful. He was shirtless at the beginning. When I flipper over, it got more sensual. He was ok with some playful touching and was nude during the HE. But that was as far as he agreed to go. 

- I may repeat if he's in my city. Because, for me, he's one of those few providers that can combine legit massage skill with quite fun mutual touching and a friendly personality. 

(Of course it helps that he is young and handsome 😉) 

[pubic_assistance]

On 12/10/2025 at 4:44 PM, SubNYCTwink said:

He was definitely encouraging and leaning into me touching him but he did stay robed. We talked after and he said he’s cool with sensual etc but just likes to keep it quasi-professional

 

On 1/8/2026 at 9:58 AM, Tonyfuntime said:

His touches feel quite sensual at "sensual" places on the body but not erotic or sexually playful. He was shirtless at the beginning. When I flipper over, it got more sensual. He was ok with some playful touching and was nude during the HE. But that was as far as he agreed to go. 

 Sounds like he's a YRMV kinda guy.

One person gets a clothed "quasi-professional" session and the other guy got a clothing-free happy ending. 

 

[Wickedsexy]

On 2/16/2026 at 8:43 AM, J-mo said:

Anyone with recent experience? Seems he is doing 4-hands too.  
 

https://rentmasseur.com/sensestwo

you sure that's the same guy ? 

[massagefan320]

I went back, I got the Miami treatment described above.  He must have gotten the memo.

[HairyDaddySam]

He’s extremely handsome and gives one of the best massages I’ve received. I go to him once a week. He always finishes me . 

[Typical]

I saw Eli a few weeks ago. His photos don’t even begin to convey his sexiness. He’s a tall, handsome, well built guy with a great smile and pleasant demeanor. He lives/ works in a nice apartment. His massage skills seemed quite good; however, in my single experience, he too quickly went for the finish. He’s positively irresistible, so…

I was in and out within 30 minutes, so I initially wrote him off for future appointments. Perhaps I will give him another try. He is a real beauty, with, I believe, real massage talent. But he needs to slow it down.

[BeefyDude]

He is in my city now.  He's HOT thats for sure.  Sounds like the massage aspect is great also.

But $220 for not even shirtless thats too high.

Unless someone can tell me otherwise.  I'm ok with just undies or no shirt.  Also NOT looking for SX, but some sensual components/touching would be nice

Feel free to reply or PM me

Thanks

[BeefyDude]

Btw has anyone taking the 4-hands plunge with him:

https://rentmasseur.com/sensestwo

$400 is actually not a bad deal for the two.  But if its just therapeutic or rub-n-tug then forget it

We know about one of them, but is the other as good at massage as well

[massagefan320]

20 hours ago, BeefyDude said:

He is in my city now.  He's HOT thats for sure.  Sounds like the massage aspect is great also.

But $220 for not even shirtless thats too high.

Unless someone can tell me otherwise.  I'm ok with just undies or no shirt.  Also NOT looking for SX, but some sensual components/touching would be nice

Feel free to reply or PM me

Thanks

He was shirtless and naked at the end the last time I saw him, see my post.

[Wickedsexy]

6 hours ago, massagefan320 said:

He was shirtless and naked at the end the last time I saw him, see my post.

Same with me

[BeefyDude]

I booked with him last night. He had ONE slot left - it was a bit late for me and I almost didn't  - BUT glad I did!!!

What a great experience.  He is an amazing young built handsome friendly guy !!!!

He brought a table with him (bonus points).   The massage was very good.

I will share that he was down to undies with me and there were some sensual (not sx-ual) aspects.

If he was local I would be all set!!

One more good thing:  When I booked he reminded me of the rate which was different from his ad. I screenshot his ad.  He said Oh yeah I need to update that.  We worked out a good compromise on the price.  

While my time wasn't quite an hour it was more than someone reported here (30 mins)

HIGHLY recommend him !!!!!!!!!