I ended up taking the plunge and seeing him tonight.
Pros: exactly as advertised. Sweet, passionate, great kisser and a helluva bottom. Was also genuinely turned on and made me feel like a stud. Cuddles and chats after.
Cons: asked for a $20 deposit initially, but was ok without it after knowing I only pay in cash. Asked for full payment upfront (was not an issue for me). Is a smoker and I could taste it slightly over the mouthwash. Finished exactly on time, but it also wasn't his place, so I don't hold it against him.
9/10, I had a great time and would repeat