Midtownguy99

Name change: https://rent.men/Thebenefit
Looks like he covered up the tattoos, but I connected to his real-world IG.

I almost forgot...he used some bullshit pina colada/banana smelling massage oil. Couldn’t wait to go home and shower that off.

No, Jack, it’s the deception. Had he come on and said, “Hi guys! I’m Rico. Check out my page at [link] and if you’re interested let me know,” that would be fine.
You don’t create a fake account and “review” yourself to drum up business.
And it’s interesting that after these posts, now he suddenly has face pics and his rates are listed as “ask me.”

He’s terrible. If you can finally get a response that he’s available for a booking, he has no problem delaying in sending his address, changing the time, and up charging during the session. He’s arrogant, and when I pointed out a discrepancy in what we agreed to beforehand to what he was offering, he said I could pay $100 more or leave. I didn’t bother insisting because he said I could leave and I did.

Escorts and massage therapists who ask for a deposit are way too precious for me. It suggests that their time is "too" important, which also suggests that money takes priority over anything else. That's a bridge too far for me. I have other more important service people in my life, and none of them require a deposit for an appointment, so why should I treat a massage or escort appointment any differently? To each his own.

@Massageislife is spot on. I've had two massages with Lorem; he free styles a sensual massage and insists on your passivity. The first massage was way better than the second. Not going back for a third.

Both of the previous messages captured much of the massage experience with Vicente. After my first time with him, I thought I would continue as a regular. He didn't give a massage in the traditional sense; it was a much gentler, constantly sensual encounter with my body. Although he is older (10 years?) than his pictures and much less ripped (I described him as a compliment as "beefy," and he didn't like it), I found him very attractive.
 
I haven't gone back since my second time with him, however, because the experience, including the part I was less satisfied with (detailed below) was almost identical. The masseurs I've kept offered an evolving, responsive massage, depending on our deepening knowledge of each other and his and my mood and needs on the given day.
 
What I didn't like was his insistence on my passivity. My hanging harm brushed against his leg once when he walked by, and I stroked his calf gently. He stopped and told me to relax and let him give me pleasure. MT, however, is part of my pleasure in an sensual/erotic massage. He also kept his bottoms on until he had turned me over, completed the "massage" of my front, and proceeded to the HE. Mutual touch was allowed then, but his focus was on getting me off, so although I enjoyed touching him, he didn't respond in any way to my touch. That makes me feel weird.
 
The guy is really nice and seemingly spiritual, but there are just too many better options for me in NYC

Shart attack?

The mind wanders and wonders…….

This guy is bad news. I don’t want to be insulting but he is as dumb as a box of rocks. I was never able to meet him but over text it sounded like a disaster. I think he has a sugar daddy so that’s why he truly doesn’t care how he interacts with clients/potential clients. 

Sad that unlicensed are fair game for whatever you want to do to them. Reminds me of prison guards who abuse prisoners and  then say that thats what they get

Is there a timeline for this site?

It's vitally important that, in the U.S. at least (I'm not sure about laws elsewhere), the masseur's livelihood NOT be put in jeopardy because of erotic, sensual or sexual talk. The NY State licensing board, for instance, will remove a person's license for what they consider "inappropriate" behavior even though the Manhattan DA said back in April 2021 that he would stop prosecuting prostitution.
Please be mindful of this. It's why THIS forum discourages that very kind of review.

Fluent in English?

Pushing back on the kissing question, mutual touch is a reasonable checkbox in an erotic massage questionnaire.  Kissing is an escort thing.  You, easygoingpal, may have had lots of luck seducing masseurs into it :-) and that's great, but masseur kissing is not a common expectation; it would fall in the category of an over-expectation.  

I hate to be crude, but I’ve often run into the masseur needing a shower. Rubbing and tugging can work up a sweat and it doesn’t take too long to ripen. So perhaps a hygiene rating? Daisy fresh to aged garlic?

Agree with most of the comments already posted.
Except: I see a need to separate out licensed masseurs.
For them nothing on this site should jeopardize their license. No mention of “erotic”, “mutual touch”, “kissing” or any similar innuendo.

Ronald cancelled on me last month at the very last second with a bullshit excuse that was not even reasonably believable. And at that point it was too late to schedule another provider. I’ll never call him again. What an asshole.

I met him, definitely much shorter than I expected. Nice guy, decent massage. Didn’t realize he was a smoker, wish I knew that before. 

I saw him at his apartment in Hudson yards  a month ago. It was a beautiful space and a he is very sexy man. The pictures were accurate. However, he seemed completely disinterested from the start. The massage portion was very short and the extras while fun, were not worth the price tag. 

I flew one guy to visit me for a weekend in NYC. He was the perfect companion and wished he could’ve stayed longer. Definitely noteworthy to add to the list. 
https://rentmen.eu/LeoMillan
Another great addition to the list is:
https://rentmen.eu/JacobTop
He used to live in NYC but moved during Covid. He visits from time to time. 
 

This guy is bad news. I don’t want to be insulting but he is as dumb as a box of rocks. I was never able to meet him but over text it sounded like a disaster. I think he has a sugar daddy so that’s why he truly doesn’t care how he interacts with clients/potential clients. 

He charges $400 per hour. That’s standard today for an upscale guy with good reviews. I feel like a lot of us guys on here get so hung up on the dollar amount.
 
If we have enough to spend on $300 guys is $100 extra really that much more if you are getting quality service from a quality guy? If it  is, then why complain? Just don’t hire the guy if it’s above your budget. I’ve seen so many posts berating guys because so many entitled men on here feel they should tell a worker their worth which I find to be so wrong. If you can’t afford a guy, then look for someone you can afford. Plain and simple. 

Met with him last year. Big muscle guy with a great ass. He bottomed for me although he doesn’t do it often and he struggled a bit. He’s mostly a top.

Sounds like you are pandering for him. Are you his agent?