Edin/MarcelloNYC---Don't Bother (why did I?)

[Thumper]

Talk about uninvolved: The petrified sweatsock I nut in nightly gives more passion.

 

Great, now I can no longer go by NYGent or Silverdollar's (other site) reviews.

 

He's SO not involved. I've never trashed an escort, never written a bad review, but when I get some time, soon, this/he will be my first. What a prick.

 

http://daddysreviews.com/newest.php?who=marcello_nyc&page=0

[JT Brooklyn]

Talk about uninvolved: The petrified sweatsock I nut in nightly gives more passion.

 

Great, now I can no longer go by NYGent or Silverdollar's (other site) reviews.

 

He's SO not involved. I've never trashed an escort, never written a bad review, but when I get some time, soon, this/he will be my first. What a prick.

 

http://daddysreviews.com/newest.php?who=marcello_nyc&page=0

 

Damn Shame! His PIX'S are some of the BEST around. His Reviews say a good time was had by all?

 

It will be interesting to read his Response when your Review does come up!

[+ glutes]

Why did you do it?? Well, you took one for the troops...

Thanks Thumper!

[Guest adnyuki]

Talk about uninvolved: The petrified sweatsock I nut in nightly gives more passion.

 

Great, now I can no longer go by NYGent or Silverdollar's (other site) reviews.

 

He's SO not involved. I've never trashed an escort, never written a bad review, but when I get some time, soon, this/he will be my first. What a prick.

 

http://daddysreviews.com/newest.php?who=marcello_nyc&page=0

 

Hey Thumper, sorry this happened. I met him some months ago and he was great, interactive, sensual etc... but perhaps he has now gotten a big head and thinks he can get away for much less input. It happens, sadly, and it is hard to keep up with these guys. Do post your review so that other buyers can be informed.

[Kevin Slater]

I'm sorry you found him lacking. He's been amazing the several times I've met up with him (both professionally and otherwise) and has been very well reviewed both in this forum and the main review site (sometimes under the name Marcello and perhaps also Danny).

 

Kevin Slater

[good ol boy]

liked him when I saw him. i do not post many reviews. as a result, he must have been good. everyone has a bad day. sometimes escorts should just say no if they are not up for the task at hand. there will always be another call. or maybe there is a chemistry thing between the client and the escort.

[Guest SilverDollar]

Very sorry to hear this. I saw him once this summer with Tommy Delucca and he was great. Review posted on MER. I just saw him again 2 weeks ago at his new place in Chelsea. Once again excellent. Can't imagine what happened.

[Bart]

Thumper not sure why you feel SilverDollar or NY Gent are to blame if the escort did not perform. Reviews are merely a guideline and I definitely feel not fool proof. I can name two popular escorts who have multiple reviews and I have had a mediocre to below average outing with. One of them was for two nights and seriously thought about just sliding the money under the door and not returning. I certainly would never consider the person doing the review has any part in it.

 

You however are doing the right thing by posting a review. I did not and now feel I should have for both individuals. The escort will have the chance to respond and you have had your say and it will be on record for future clients. Unfortunately for me both of these outings occurred about 3 years ago cant do anything about it now but that is what reviews or for even the mediocre ones.

[uwsman2]

so sorry to hear this

 

I'm so sorry to hear this. The picture is totally hot on that review and from prior reviewers it sounds like he was somebody worth trying out. Of course, individual experiences with escorts can differ. Like some of the guys who responded above, I have had less than stellar experiences with some well-reviewed guys. Chemistry is important, and everybody has an off-day now and then.

[6832white]

I agree with Thumper. I called on Edin a month ago based on positive reviews he got here at Hooboy. Ok, he has a so-so body and average looks -- nothing to rave about. He's the kind of guy where being nice goes a long way, if you know want I mean. But I felt he was aloof, almost arrogant. After about 40 minutes, he said he had to leave but had the nerve to ask me if I'd call again. The kissing was average and there was no reciprocation whatsoever in any of the contacts. In this market, really, I could do better and I will not call again.

[6832white]

I agree

 

I agree with Thumper. I called on Edin about a month ago based on positive reviews I got from this site. He has average looks and a so-so body, actually a bit on the thin side. He was the kind of guy who would go much farther if he has a great personality. But he was aloof, a bit arrogant and not very interactive. After 40 minutes, he had to go but he also had the nerve to ask if I'd call again. The kissing was very uninteresting and there was no reciprocation whatsoever with the action. In this market, I would not call again but would rather call someone else.

[bcohen7719]

I emailed Edin once or twice. He replied in a very, very nice way.

[JT Brooklyn]

bcohen. Welcome Newbie! Why you are commenting on a Thread almost a Year Old with a Negative Heading on Edin makes No Sense?

 

It would make more sense IF you "Hired the Guy" and wrote a nice REVIEW to go along with his NICE EMAIL Replies to you in the Last Year!

 

WELCOME TO THE FORUMS!

[Steven_Draker]

Why you are commenting on a Thread almost a Year Old with a Negative Heading on Edin makes No Sense?

 

Probably because he's looking to hire Edin ...

 

http://www.companyofmen.org/showthread.php?76024-NYC-Escorts&p=673458#post673458

 

and he was told to do a search on him and looking for additional info.

 

Welcome, bcohen7719 !

 

Hugs, Steven ~

[geon777]

I agree with Thumper. I hired Edin couple of weeks ago, mainly because his pictures look amazing. I have to say he photographs well. In reality he is not that impressive, more on the feminine site. But this was not the problem. He was aloof not interactive to the point of being obnoxious. No kissing no sucking because it was not "safe". Every time I tried to get close to his ass he will scream and complain. Again not "safe". I paid him in advance and 20 min. into the session he said I "must come and then go"... So I asked him to massage me since he advertises as a masseuse as well. The same unengaged lame performance. So 30 min. into the session I left. I was baffled that this happened because I am always very respectful and nice and I never received such a response from an escort. Didn't bother to write a review. But now that I red the thread I thought it would be helpful for every one else if I share my experience.

[seeker630]

A review would help future potential clients make a more informed decision.

[instudiocity]

I agree with Thumper. I hired Edin couple of weeks ago, mainly because his pictures look amazing. I have to say he photographs well. In reality he is not that impressive, more on the feminine site. But this was not the problem. He was aloof not interactive to the point of being obnoxious. No kissing no sucking because it was not "safe". Every time I tried to get close to his ass he will scream and complain. Again not "safe". I paid him in advance and 20 min. into the session he said I "must come and then go"... So I asked him to massage me since he advertises as a masseuse as well. The same unengaged lame performance. So 30 min. into the session I left. I was baffled that this happened because I am always very respectful and nice and I never received such a response from an escort. Didn't bother to write a review. But now that I red the thread I thought it would be helpful for every one else if I share my experience.

 

Please WRITE a REVIEW!

[JT Brooklyn]

Terrible Experience BUT NO Review?

 

I agree with Thumper. I hired Edin couple of weeks ago, mainly because his pictures look amazing. I have to say he photographs well. In reality he is not that impressive, more on the feminine site. But this was not the problem. He was aloof not interactive to the point of being obnoxious. No kissing no sucking because it was not "safe". Every time I tried to get close to his ass he will scream and complain. Again not "safe". I paid him in advance and 20 min. into the session he said I "must come and then go"... So I asked him to massage me since he advertises as a masseuse as well. The same unengaged lame performance. So 30 min. into the session I left. I was baffled that this happened because I am always very respectful and nice and I never received such a response from an escort. Didn't bother to write a review. But now that I red the thread I thought it would be helpful for every one else if I share my experience.

 

Hey Newbie..Sounds like you really had a miserable time and most guys would have submited a Review the NEXT DAY!

 

Anyone who takes this Forum "Seriously" knows that any NEGATIVE comments in a REVIEW towards a Working Guy should be able to get some RESPONSE from the Working Guy ..since he is given the Opportunity before a Review is Posted!

 

So to be FAIR to EDIN Submit it!

 

Especially since you say it was so recent?

 

IF you choose not to ...it is no more than idle DELI Chit-Chat! IMHO of course!

[Lewis H]

Please WRITE a REVIEW![/size][/font]

 

Yes, because long after this thread is dead and buried, and escorts in question have changed their names, pics and links, the reviews are a permanent record that people could hopefully search and glean helpful advice from before they hire!

[+ glutes]

Yes, because long after this thread is dead and buried, and escorts in question have changed their names, pics and links, the reviews are a permanent record that people could hopefully search and glean helpful advice from before they hire!

 

Another reason the reviews are useless...

 

Fortunately we do have a good search engine here!

[bcohen7719]

You're right, of course. I'm new to the forum/reviews, and any ground-rules are also new to me. In all honesty, I've never hired an escort (ever) and am actually nervous about it.

[doitb4ugo]

You're right, of course. I'm new to the forum/reviews, and any ground-rules are also new to me. In all honesty, I've never hired an escort (ever) and am actually nervous about it.

 

Take it from a ex-newbie, when I joined this forum, I was as dumb as a bag of hammers. It proved to be a very good place to learn and grow. My firt escort experience was not what i thought...These things all happen. Best advice belongs to PurpleKow....It's only sex. If you don;t get it right, you can do it again (to paraphrase). I realize it is easier said than done...but you will grow and learn like we all had to. Welcome and hold onto your hat.

[+ glutes]

You're right, of course. I'm new to the forum/reviews, and any ground-rules are also new to me. In all honesty, I've never hired an escort (ever) and am actually nervous about it.

 

 

Sounds like Edin / Marcello would not be a good first choice...

[wayout]

You're right, of course. I'm new to the forum/reviews, and any ground-rules are also new to me. In all honesty, I've never hired an escort (ever) and am actually nervous about it.

 

I totally understand your nervousness about your first hire. It has been a long time since my first hire and it is a vague memory but I do very much recall how nervous I was (beyond being nervous to be honest). I do believe you have a great advantage by having the review site and participating in the forum, both of which I was not aware of until after a few poor experiences but since it has proved to be an invaluable resource. So welcome and hope you enjoy your adventure, and certainly keep us all posted on how it goes.

[geon777]

Thank you. I agree. A review would have been helpful. However, I noticed that when I read the reviews and the postings on the Forum and then compare my experience with a particular escort the information I find on the Forum is more accurate. Anyways, I have made my point and so did at least two other guys on the Forum. Hope it will help.