Newbie in NYC: Karl_Kelso

[tallandark]

Cannot say enough good things about him. 

[+ Gar1eth]

Anyone know where in Texas he's from?

[r_curious]

Just verifying all of these replies. If you want more details you can hit me up but he was the perfect person to meet up in NYC if you’re into a tall, handsome man. 

PS - he’s a great kisser! 

[darkprinze]

Anyone know if his premium content shares face pics? 

[ShortCutie7]

37 minutes ago, darkprinze said:

Anyone know if his premium content shares face pics? 

While I do not have access to premium content, I can say with 99% certainty that he would not share face pics.  But you can trust us when we’re all saying that (regardless of whatever your personal preference is) he is objectively an incredibly handsome man… my best description would be to imagine if Superman were a catalog model.

[ER12321]

8 hours ago, ShortCutie7 said:

While I do not have access to premium content, I can say with 99% certainty that he would not share face pics.  But you can trust us when we’re all saying that (regardless of whatever your personal preference is) he is objectively an incredibly handsome man… my best description would be to imagine if Superman were a catalog model.

I have a premium account and no, Karl_Kelso does not share face pics, but yes, he is definitely handsome!

[BrklynNYC]

9 hours ago, ShortCutie7 said:

While I do not have access to premium content, I can say with 99% certainty that he would not share face pics.  But you can trust us when we’re all saying that (regardless of whatever your personal preference is) he is objectively an incredibly handsome man… my best description would be to imagine if Superman were a catalog model.

 

55 minutes ago, ER12321 said:

I have a premium account and no, Karl_Kelso does not share face pics, but yes, he is definitely handsome!

Would that be a young Christopher Reeve?

[Callas]

3 minutes ago, BrklynNYC said:

 

Would that be a young Christopher Reeve?

Would that be too good to be true?

[BananaBagel]

Caught up with Karl recently and he’s looking so great. He told me he’s changing up his workouts and looking even better than ever. With the same heart and joy for life. He’s really the best. 

[dutchal]

https://rentmen.eu/Karl_Kelso

[inquisitivespinach]

Wish I could add something positive here.

Reached out to Karl_Kelso via the number posted. Got a response. Things seemed to be going well.

I asked for his rate. And then the next message from him was saying he didn’t want to meet anymore.

I found the interaction a bit strange considering all the glowing reviews.

[Pillowtalk]

2 hours ago, inquisitivespinach said:

Wish I could add something positive here.

Reached out to Karl_Kelso via the number posted. Got a response. Things seemed to be going well.

I asked for his rate. And then the next message from him was saying he didn’t want to meet anymore.

I found the interaction a bit strange considering all the glowing reviews.

He pretty much did the same to me today and said good luck. What a weird interaction. 

[Joekgames]

I had tried to book in advance and told him I was looking for a date two weeks ahead. He asked me to reach out to him the week of. I then messaged him a few days later to ask if he was available on a specific date and he responded by telling me I clearly do not how to respect boundaries or follow directions and then promptly blocked me. 🤷🏻‍♂️

[Chilltime]

I had a similarly weird interaction with him.  I am not sure he wants clients 

[rawview]

I didn't have a positive experience with this provider.  Our schedules were just not connecting and rather than working to find a time he just blocked me.  It was very surprising because we didn't have a bad interaction or anything disrespectful.  It was the only time this happened in my years of hiring professionals.  

[Midtownm4m]

I had the same interaction with him- he seems to have a low tolerance on text or messenger. 

 

[+ Gar1eth]

We obviously can't know what's going on in his head or his life. But it seems to me that NYC has enough escorts-that unless you just like trying to pursue things off the beaten track-I'd go for someone else. 

[NewYorkChelsea]

6 hours ago, rawview said:

I didn't have a positive experience with this provider.  Our schedules were just not connecting and rather than working to find a time he just blocked me.  It was very surprising because we didn't have a bad interaction or anything disrespectful.  It was the only time this happened in my years of hiring professionals.  

I had a similar experience — after we couldn’t get schedules to mesh (an issue on his end as much as mine) he blocked me. 

[DiscreetHungBrooklyn88]

On 4/16/2026 at 5:42 PM, inquisitivespinach said:

Wish I could add something positive here.

Reached out to Karl_Kelso via the number posted. Got a response. Things seemed to be going well.

I asked for his rate. And then the next message from him was saying he didn’t want to meet anymore.

I found the interaction a bit strange considering all the glowing reviews.

 

On 4/16/2026 at 8:25 PM, Pillowtalk said:

He pretty much did the same to me today and said good luck. What a weird interaction. 

 

On 4/16/2026 at 8:45 PM, Joekgames said:

I had tried to book in advance and told him I was looking for a date two weeks ahead. He asked me to reach out to him the week of. I then messaged him a few days later to ask if he was available on a specific date and he responded by telling me I clearly do not how to respect boundaries or follow directions and then promptly blocked me. 🤷🏻‍♂️

 

On 4/16/2026 at 11:10 PM, Chilltime said:

I had a similarly weird interaction with him.  I am not sure he wants clients 

 

On 4/17/2026 at 2:07 AM, rawview said:

I didn't have a positive experience with this provider.  Our schedules were just not connecting and rather than working to find a time he just blocked me.  It was very surprising because we didn't have a bad interaction or anything disrespectful.  It was the only time this happened in my years of hiring professionals.  

 

On 4/17/2026 at 5:56 AM, Midtownm4m said:

I had the same interaction with him- he seems to have a low tolerance on text or messenger. 

 

 

On 4/17/2026 at 6:28 AM, Gar1eth said:

We obviously can't know what's going on in his head or his life. But it seems to me that NYC has enough escorts-that unless you just like trying to pursue things off the beaten track-I'd go for someone else. 

 

On 4/17/2026 at 8:30 AM, NewYorkChelsea said:

I had a similar experience — after we couldn’t get schedules to mesh (an issue on his end as much as mine) he blocked me. 

Okay wow this is extremely validating. 
 

I am so new to this community and had seen the great reviews here and was messaging him texting to schedule a first visit and clarify questions. I am an extremely friendly texter and respectful and never rude (at least I like to think so). When I tried to schedule a week or two in advance he was extremely cold and dismissive and I had a funny gut instinct sometime felt off but decided to ignore it. Then I tried to reach out to him another time (following his instruction) to schedule the same day and when it didn’t work out, he insulted me in a very cruel way and blocked me. I was really worried I had committed some faux pas and not realized it and felt terrible, but this morning seeing a half dozen others recently had the same experience honestly makes me feel better that it wasn’t something I did and is something about the provider.