For me these would have been the top 5 finalists:
Justin- My mother loved Justin Hayward and wanted to call me this but my father said no.
Nolan- Just in general a really nice well-rounded name.
Joshua- Classic and yet sounds still modern.
Jason- Strong, elegant.
Kyle- Just cool.
Here are the most common names from 1985, the year I was born: (You can change the year with the drop-down menu)
https://www.behindthename.com/top/lists/united-states/1985