I agree. I don't understand this sudden interest in growing a mustache. I run into a number of cute young guys at the gym who've gone that route and it immediately turns me off.
I was there in October and saw Victor. For some reason I can't paste the link to him on Rentmasseur when using my iPhone. He goes by the name "artsandrituals" when you type in Tokyo as the location. I had a great experience with him and would highly recommend.
I set up an appointment with him when I was in Vegas. He was responsive and clear about what to expect. In the end, he never showed up for the appointment and didn't respond to multiple texts. I was incredibly annoyed because the time scheduled was toward the end of my time in Vegas and had I known this was going to be his game I would have booked elsewhere. As far as the pictures, I first saw him on another website and those pictures have been up for years. I've blocked his number and wouldn't waste my time on him. That's my two cents!
I agree with your sentiments about the site. I, too, found myself taken by his ad over the years. If he were in my area, I would've reached out but that's now a no go because of the reviews. I am also grateful for the this site