Some of this list is going to date me, but here goes:
Josh Weston
Talvin DeMacchio
Rick Hammersmith
Juice
Rod Daily
Mike Grey
Marco Rossi
AJ Irons
Marc Dylan
Lucas di Fubbiano
CJ Knight
Luka
Apollo Phoenix
Victor Powers
Matt Stevens
Gianfranco
Aaron Mark
Johnny V
Alec Andrews
Ricky Decker
Avidar
Lesterr
Devon
Mathianis
Ian Park (off the clock)
Battlecat
Asisoy
Tristan Gaul
Donato Reyes
Edit add: Rafael Briggs
There were a few others whose names I don't remember. One was a guy in Chicago who was so hot that we had only gotten our shirts off and were making out when I came in my pants. I saw him a couple of times (and lasted longer the next time, thankfully), but he was one of those bodybuilders who kept on getting bigger and bigger to the point where I thought he'd lost his hotness. There was another guy who was visiting New York with an Olympic gymnast's body, Italian or Hispanic but just a little bit of dark hair on a pale caramel complexion. For some reason he drove me absolutely crazy and I came three times before the hour was up. Then there was this Venezuelan guy, built like Ricky Decker but even hotter, darker complected and bald--he did this undressing dance for me exhibiting phenomenal control of his body (I could see every muscle move), just out of my reach, that had me so heated up, I came at the first moment my hands actually touched him. And this one is really going to date me. Back when you could actually hook up, two to a buddy booth at the porn arcades, I caught the eye of a Hispanic guy with a beautiful complexion, who looked like he had a good body under his clothes. When we got in the booth, and he took off his shirt, I was left breathless at seeing one one of the most beautiful bodies I have ever seen, before or since. Tried to get his name and number, but no dice. Went back there more than once hoping to see him again, but no luck. This was about forty years ago, so the fact that this memory stuck with me tells you just how gorgeous he was. And let me add one more. There was this guy on rentboy who had a drop dead, traffic stopping body. There were rumors here about his drug use, but I took a chance. There was good news and bad news. His body matched the pics or better--exquisite! And he did everything I wanted. The bad news was that the drug rumors understated the issue. There was paraphernalia everywhere in his apartment, even broken glass on the floor in one spot, and clutter everywhere to the point where I wondered how this guy functioned. It still amazes me how a guy could abuse substances that much and still keep a body that was the envy of almost all of malekind when most of the rest of us could work out three times a day and still not come close to the beauty he enjoyed. I can't even imagine where his habits led him, but unless he got really lucky or had the benefit of serious intervention, I doubt he's in a good place today.