*Spas in NYC

[jbro]

On 1/14/2026 at 9:08 PM, JohnnyG said:

I'll just stick to Renew-  always great experience especially with the one guy

Which renew is this?  Seems like a few places with similar names. Who do you recommend there?

[Big_Willi]

On 1/14/2026 at 9:08 PM, JohnnyG said:

I'll just stick to Renew-  always great experience especially with the one guy

Yeah Man is the only real gay massage spa in Chinatown that I know.

[jay524]

Anyone been to renew York spa on 8th Ave in HK lately ? I saw some google reviews about a new masseur there .. 

[JayinHKNYC]

I tried All Seasons on 9th and 42nd/43rd (mixed staff, and they had at least 3 male masseurs). I previously had been to Four Seasons on 9th and 47th/48th a couple of times (they have at least 2 male masseurs).

Four Seasons has consistently given purely therapeutic treatment with not much sensual touch and about as much pressure as you want. All Seasons was the opposite. If you want a more soothing, light touch and to leave happy, they may be a better option (obviously YMMV).

[+ Tarte Gogo]

3 hours ago, JayinHKNYC said:

I tried All Seasons on 9th and 42nd/43rd (mixed staff, and they had at least 3 male masseurs). I previously had been to Four Seasons on 9th and 47th/48th a couple of times (they have at least 2 male masseurs).

Four Seasons has consistently given purely therapeutic treatment with not much sensual touch and about as much pressure as you want. All Seasons was the opposite. If you want a more soothing, light touch and to leave happy, they may be a better option (obviously YMMV).

Interesting to know about All season, but what kind of guy do they have?

I don’t want a happy ending from someone that I don’t find attractive.

[luvhusky]

21 hours ago, JayinHKNYC said:

I tried All Seasons on 9th and 42nd/43rd (mixed staff, and they had at least 3 male masseurs). I previously had been to Four Seasons on 9th and 47th/48th a couple of times (they have at least 2 male masseurs).

Four Seasons has consistently given purely therapeutic treatment with not much sensual touch and about as much pressure as you want. All Seasons was the opposite. If you want a more soothing, light touch and to leave happy, they may be a better option (obviously YMMV).

I used to go to the all seasons in Astoria and this never happened except once where the guy totally made me spurt. And never saw him again. I think it was just random and he got fired. However I did like it for therapeutic 

[Massadict]

NYC spa threads seem quiet.. is the freezing cold affecting these spas? I’m thinking of getting a massage today but wanted to check if there is anything I should be aware of.

[Big_Willi]

You could try a 24-hour mens spa in the city. They’re usually still open and not really affected by the cold, especially at night

[deepplease]

Oh Alven.  Go see him if you haven’t.  Many years later he never disappoints  gulp !  

[luvhusky]

On 1/14/2026 at 9:08 PM, JohnnyG said:

I'll just stick to Renew-  always great experience especially with the one guy

Which renew? Which guy?

[Horatio]

On 12/19/2025 at 9:17 AM, BrklynNYC said:

Go for Jay at spa 27. Excellent massage. Amazing shape. 

 

[Horatio]

Jay at 27 is amazing looking, but gives lousy massage even after soliciting bigger tip. He’s great looking, tho (formerly aka Joy)

[Horatio]

On 12/29/2024 at 6:47 PM, parkneedler said:

I really want to try Jay at 27 just because of how he looks – anyone have experience and know how he handles tip?

 

[Horatio]

Jay at 27 gave me a lousy massage and solicited tips from me 3 times throughout the massage. Lots of weak one-handed massaging. I don’t recommend him at all, but he looks fantastic. 

[Horatio]

On 1/5/2025 at 11:40 PM, Sam C said:

Jay at 27 is outstanding.  He is very dedicated to his work.  You won’t be disappointed!!

 

[Horatio]

On 1/6/2025 at 1:04 AM, dreamboy13 said:

Why does this sound like Jay at Batman wrote this 

Ditto on Jay at Batman. He is awesome. If you like both a great strong massage and all the extras on steroids then Jay is your guy. He caters to what you like. 

[BrklynNYC]

4 hours ago, Horatio said:

Jay at 27 is amazing looking, but gives lousy massage even after soliciting bigger tip. He’s great looking, tho (formerly aka Joy)

Jay is not the same as Joy. Jay is asian and Joy is Latino.