Unless I've missed it due to this being a long thread, you never actually told us what kind of guy you like, @5280Dane. That might tailor the suggestions better
Most of the guys I did weekends with have retired-for example Andrew Justice and Alec Andrews were incredible people to spend time with.
Of those currently advertising I will definitely 2nd a previous recommendation of Mike Gaite. He's the boy next door all grown up and even hunkier. He's totally versatile, a great kisser, into some kink if you like but great with vanilla, and is a good cuddler.
https://rent.men/MikeGaite/
If you like older, Matt Stevens (again another second) would probably be good. I only did overnights with him.
https://rent.men/MattStevens
Another older guy who advertises from time to time is Ray Stone out of NYC. I don't think his ad is up currently.
If you are willing to go international, then try Dean Monroe from London. He's versatile but prefers to bottom.
https://rent.men/Deanmonroex
I hope these help.
Gman