I’ve been to Renew york many times. It’s a mixed spa, mostly legit. Massage quality is a little hit or miss, but not bad or sketchy.
If you’re looking for interactive, avoid Owen, Michael, and Leo. Michael’s massage was a little painful, not my favorite.
There is one guy who does more but he’s older with a sort of dad bod and he only works a couple days. There are threads about this already and obviously don’t want to put him in jeopardy by mentioning his name.