Same experience. Nice guy, thin but toned body, good kisser, good masseur. Loves to eat ass. One hour massage was closer to two hours. No upcharge. I'd hire again next time I'm in LA.
I know it's subjective and I'm an outlier on this site, but cockrings, piercings, and especially tattoos are a huge turnoff for me. I want my men unadorned as god intended. (Big exception for Christopher Meloni!)