It all varies. What I look for is sexiness. I have had guys with
ho-hum bodies and guys with ho-hum faces, but makes them work
for me is that the personality projects sexiness.
I tend to groove on personality (or what is being projected as
a personality for the session). My best time with an escort
wasn't what most people consider handsome (unless you like
cropped-hair leather clone look) and not the best body (very
tall and lanky), but he projected a mischevious sexiness. Of
course he had a big shvantz perfectly angled for deep-throating
and more, but still it was his sexiness that brought me back.