I had a good experience in Hicksville but let's just say the masseur should have filed one nail a little better, ha ha. I also tried Prime in Mineola and Bin did an amazing job. It started with massage through a towel, which I don't love but I decided to be patient with that. It improved greatly after that so I'd return but ask to skip the towel next time. To answer Cruiser7's question, I ask who to ask for when I return.
Does anyone know if the Plandome location in Manhasset is still a good option? I can't find current contact info for them.
Are there any massage exchange sites on Long Island?