I ended up taking the plunge. He looks just like his photos and is actually a really nice and welcoming guy with a sexy deep voice. Starts by introducing himself, asks a few basic questions about any injuries and such.
FYI: the massage is 100% professional. He is fully clothed in his scrubs and then asks you to undress down to underwear and adds a towel over. Which is fine for me.
Overall, nice guy, surprisingly great massage. I'd return in the future for a legitimate and professional massage.