Had a great time reading this thread. Thank you.
Great experiences:
The original Broadway production of Dreamgirls with Jennifer Holliday. During AND I AM TELLING YOU I'M NOT GOING, people were lifted out of their seats and then standing on their seats, screaming as the curtain came down on the first act. Great show, great production. I used to second act it as well.
I saw that last revival of Carol Channing's Hello Dolly in Denver before it came into Broadway. It's an old warhorse of a musical and I didn't have high expectations, however, it does have a good book and score. Channing was amazing. Seeing her up there carrying that musical so brilliantly actually brought me to tears.
The Scottsboro Boys was fantastic.
Music Man is my favorite of the older shows, haven't seen the current production yet.
Not so great experiences:
Contact was... oy. I thought, you gotta be kidding me. I thought that girl on swing number wound never end. Broadway ticket price with canned music, left at intermission.
Once. It seemed everyone I knew was raving about this show, crying, holding their hearts. I guess I'm a heartless bastard, I wanted to take the guitar away from the leading man.
Cats.
Oh, and I saw a regional production of 1776 I really liked except the actor playing Rutledge (sings Molasses to Rum to Slaves) had a bilateral lisp.