Am. Idol Tonight ("Spoiler Alert" for Central to West Coast Fans)

[ariadne1880]

David Archuleta's voice has not "matured" enough but to me David Cook's voice already sounds worn out. Who has more potential? The answer is obvious to me. And it's a singing competition not a "who is the best musician" competition.

 

Archuleta is the best singer, hands down. He touches people. Cook just makes me wince every time he reaches for a note -- high or low. That's not my idea -- nor should it be anyone's -- of what singing is.

 

He's just a tired rocker. I don't really think that is what American Idol is all about.

 

Mark

[ariadne1880]

Who cares who is a fag or not. The problem is that Castro ACTS like such a fag. And it's not attractive. He also seeems to be on drugs all the time -- which is far worse.

 

Mark

[Guest ReturnOfS]

>>

>>42% Jason Castro

>>27% Brooke White

>>18% Syesha Mercado

>>10% David Archuleta

>>3% David Cook

>>

>>

>>I posted it here...just for fun...see how the website's

>polls

>>stand to a reality check! :)remember folks: JUST FOR

>FUN!

>>

>>:-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-)

>

>

>Interesting! Jason Castro (loves those blue eyes and his long

>legs all wrapped in tight blue jeans!) survived the cut!

>

>Many blogs, pollsters and bulletin forecasts predicted he will

>go away after tonight --Oh boy...He is well ensconced in the

>TOP FOUR! I believe Jason Castro has a very big base of

>followers that cross bounderies (again, I said I...means it

>is my opinion, based on a hunch!)

>

>

>I dont know but, somehow,I thought he was the underdog! and

>America likes the underdog!

>

>I convinced a lot of my friends and family to vote for him

>last Tuesday night ... like I did ( I successfully cast more

>than 20 phone viotes and 20 text votes! ) I do believe that

>David A has a better chance at the finals togther with David

>C...but for now, I do want Jason Castro to stay! He may be

>prissy or effeminate has the worst voice and singing style o

>the top five BUT! he has got the balls that ring my bells!

>-- He is beautiful, has a certain vulnerability in his

>voice and most of all -- he is pushing himself to his limits!

>I was just mesmerized to cast my votes for him (first tme for

>me! lol) These are good enough reasons for me to vote for

>him. Maybe most of the 45 M American Idol voters think like

>I do. Thus he is safe!

>

>I know...I know...American Idol is a SINGING competition! Do

>you think I care? it is my time that I wasted voting for him,

>my text messages ... my telephone and fingers that were used

>to contribute to Jason Castro's being in the TOP FOUR! Am I

>voting for the wrong contestant ? Try telling that to the

>people, who like me, were patiently and methodically dialing

>to vote for Jason Castro!

>

>

>:-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-)

 

Good to see another Jason fan, but you seem so apologetic. Why? I like has voice. You don't need permission to think that someone has a good voice... Definitely better than mine.

 

Btw, since there are only 4 contestants left there is at least a 1 in 4 chance that any of the blogs may be correct about any of the contestants to be voted off.

[Guest ReturnOfS]

As long as you're not doing name calling because of a contestant that I like, you're definitely entitled to your opinion.

[ariadne1880]

"Liking" someone's voice and thinking a voice is "good" is two different things.

 

No vocal coach or teacher of any note would make any claim that Jason Castro has a "good voice." It's a pathetic.

 

Voting for someone because you like their "balls" or because you are ill-informed is about as immature as it gets.

 

Both of the above posts sound like they were written by 12 year old girls.

 

Mark

[Guest CURIOUS35]

>

>Good to see another Jason fan,

 

I likeJason C...first time I saw him on American Idol a few weeks back, i was hooked on him...not American Idol... He is the dark horse to make the final three. If he becomes Top Three, I will be content! I have voted the last time and i intend to vote again (several times and ways!) I intend to make my admiration for him ne known thru my votes!

 

 

 

but you seem so apologetic.

 

I am not apologetic or anything...far from it...I post from the heart...not someone assuming a persona! I did write a caveat --What I wrote is a personal opinion -- and I reminded whoever reads my post...THAT! I think sometimes, some bloggers forget that very important aspect of a posted response -- which is Intent and purpose!

 

>Why? I like has voice.

 

I do too... He has some vocal flaws with a tonal quality uniquely his own, that make him more reachable for me...the feeling of ...maybe...maybe...I can meet him too! *wink*

 

You don't need permission to think that someone has a good voice... Definitely better than mine.

 

I can not render an opinion on that! I have not heard you sing---YET!

>

 

>BtW, since there are only 4 contestants left there is at least

>a 1 in 4 chance that any of the blogs may be correct about any

>of the contestants to be voted off.

 

Do you play Vegas?

 

Thanks for your response to my post...I appreciate it!

 

 

 

>

:-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-)

[Guest ReturnOfS]

http://rollmops.files.wordpress.com/2007/04/muppets-statlerwaldorf.jpg

 

hmmmm... I'd say grumpy guy on the right