You will get many varied responses to this post.
Like you, I think I pay a premium for physical traits - great physique, beautiful face, etc. - but I have had some experiences where I Have been in a room with a Greek god I've hired - and I can't wait for him to leave.
So simply put, there's more than just the physical. That extra something will be different for everyone. Right now, I'm leaning more towards guys who are fit, attractive, reliable and respectful / and that combo is getting harder to find. That's why the Mike Gaites and Tristan Baldwins are few and far between.