My list:
Marcus Iron - amazing kisser; great eye contact
Allen Silver - all-around sensual lover
Drew Sebastian - one of the biggest cocks I've had
Billy Wild - nice but a little boring
Bryce Anderson - one of my favorites. Had a really good connection. Great kisser
Damien Stone - the best legs. Will probably hire again
Jake Deckard - hired for massage a few times and things have always progressed. Another great kisser and beautiful ass.
Coming up this weekend: Damon Andros
I hired him about 6 months ago and would recommend him. Great kisser (very important to me), amazing cocksucker (seems to REALLY enjoy it), and seems very smart. Like he says, not the biggest dick in the room, but he knows how to use.
Hired him once. Wouldn't recommend. Didn't get hard (could be a grower, but definitely not a shower). Some body acne (from 'roids, maybe?). Did give me a good blow job, though. Lives in Guerneville so maybe why he says he's out of town so often.