I think we covered this topic not too long ago, but since lube is one of my fetishes, let's refresh~
For lube wrestling, body contact or when i know i may be covered from head-to-toe by the end of a session, i try to stick with a waterbased lube (sans Nonoxydol-9) like Wet Light or the new Eros Water, both of which easily clean up and remain NON-sticky. For those Costco-conscious shoppers out there, Wet Light sells pretty cheaply in a convienient pump 'orgy size' bottle.
On the issue of Nonoxydol-9, it's best to STAY AWAY from any lube with this as it's included ingredient. It's been recently found to actually cause anal irritation, thus making any transfer of STD's easier. This rule should also apply to condoms. If i happen to be using condoms that have Nonoxydol-9 already applied, i simply use a little water, silicone or oil-based (if it's a polyurethane condom of course) lube to 'wash' it off and then jump into things.
For fingering, anal, j/o and heavier play, i tend to go with silicone or oil-based lubes. They last longer, lubricate better and can take a licking and keep on ticking (literally). Elbow Grease, Eros, Vaseline, Crisco, ID-Cream (j/o formula), among others have been really pleasurable for me in the bedroom. Cleanup might not always be easy, but it gives you a chance to have someone else jump in the shower with you and help scrub it all off
*grin*
I'm aware that Wet Platinum has it's own afterwash, but since trying Eros, i'm not much of a Wet user anymore. Added, the Wet afterwash can be used for just about any silicone-based lube.
Just keep in mind that when using oil-based lubes during anal play, you MUST use a polyurethane condom (ie, Avanti, Trojan Supra). Latex will breakdown when throwing oil into the mix, so make sure to spring the extra cash and buy the poly condoms. On the plus side, they transmit bodyheat better and are 10x as stong as latex...
The lubes i don't recommend? KY Jelly (gets too goopy and messes with sensation), Frixxion (dried out my dick, not cool), Baby Oil (smells like a baby's ass and provides minimal lubrication), Trojan-brand lubes (They're really made for vaginal sex) and flavored lubes (if i wanted to suck dick and taste kiwi, i'd blow the Kool-Aid Man). I've also tried the Pheremone lube that Wet puts out (in the green bottle): It was alright, but didn't add anything extra to the mix...
Well, now that i've given a whole lecture on the merits & evils of lube, go forth and fornicate. *grin* If you need any weblinks to find any of the aformentioned lubes at a good price, privately email me and we'll chat.
Warmest Always,
Benjamin Nicholas