PhillyMassageFan

There are a couple of online sites, massageexchange.com, freerub, etc, but require a subscription to make any meaningful communication. 

There used to be a nationwide 'club' called Massage Mates. A newsletter sent via snail mail included a list of guys (gay, bi, "straight") around the country with their stats, personal statement, massage experience, and phone number. Some even had tables. There were always some who preferred to receive only and not exchange.
I had some great sessions but declined many others. However, it never adapted to the internet. 

If there are any guys interested in this concept in Manhattan, I'd consider it.  If they can host,  I'd bring drinks & snacks.  We'd have a grand ole time!  😄  

He gives you a massage. You give him a massage. Both of you are amateurs who enjoy touching and being touched.
Some guys are into this.