Jump to content

Republican Family Values: Calling disabled kids "vegetables".

This topic is 6547 days old and is no longer open for new replies.  Replies are automatically disabled after two years of inactivity.  Please create a new topic instead of posting here.  

Recommended Posts

Just when you think it can't get any worse, it does.





'Vegetable' comment prompts call for lawmaker's resignation

Posted at 1:45 p.m. December 22

By the Associated Press


HELENA - Some state lawmakers and school administrators are calling for the removal of Rep.-elect and current Sen. Ed Butcher from a legislative education committee after he called developmentally disabled students "vegetables" during a recent meeting.


Butcher, R-Winifred, dubbed his comment at a Dec. 14 meeting of central Montana school superintendents "an unfortunate choice of words," but has refused to formally apologize.


"I think I've said what I'm going to say," Butcher told Lee Newspapers on Tuesday. "This thing where people have to grovel around and apologize for everything they say irritates me."


Columbus schools superintendent Allan Sipes, who will become president of the School Administrators of Montana next year, called Butcher's behavior "reprehensible."


"It's mind-blowing that we would have someone in a position like his, who is so out of it," Sipes said. "I believe that he should be pulled from the Education Committee and replaced with someone who understands and cares about all kids."


House Speaker-elect Roy Brown, R-Billings, appointed Butcher to the House Education Committee for the 2005 Legislature, which starts Jan. 3.


Butcher could not run for his current Senate seat because of changes caused by redistricting, filing to run for House District 29 instead.


Brown said Tuesday he wanted to talk with Butcher before commenting further. He did not immediately return a phone call from The Associated Press on Wednesday.


Senate Education Committee Chair Don Ryan, D-Great Falls, said Wednesday he felt Butcher's constituents should decide his fate, although he did not agree with the senator's comments.


"We all learn in different ways, we function in different ways, we're physically different," he told the AP. "Honestly, one of the things we try to do in schools and in everything we do is to fight the one disability everybody starts with and that's ignorance."


At last week's meeting, Butcher said "vegetables," or seriously disabled students, should be removed from the traditional school setting and relocated in regional hub schools that can better meet their needs. Montana's schools, he said, currently cannot afford to do that.


"These kids definitely need to be put in a special place," Butcher told Lee on Tuesday. "It may even be a nursing home setting to give them the best quality of life they can have."


Butcher told Lee he's sensitive to the needs of disabled children and has some disabled family members.


Butcher, 61, is also being criticized for comments he made about minority students during the same meeting. He said Nevada pays its teachers more because they have to "deal" with a more diverse student population.


"Montana teachers who leave the state for better paying jobs elsewhere have to deal with groups of Hispanic, Asian and black gangs that are terrorizing schools," Butcher told Lee in explaining his comments.


House Minority Leader-elect Dave Wanzenried, D-Missoula, said members of Butcher's own party should call for his resignation so they aren't perceived as endorsing his comments.


"His resignation couldn't come too early for me," Wanzenried said. "I don't think anybody with those prejudices should be in public service anywhere."


Rep. Tom Facey, D-Missoula, said such situations aren't new to Butcher, a former teacher and professor who was criticized during the 2001 Legislature for referring to American Indian reservations as ghettos.


"I predict he will keep saying those things," Facey said. "He's been saying those things since the first day he served in the Senate. If Republicans want him to say those things then so be it."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest msclonly



This was in another string, but it really fits in here, as well.


These kind of accusations are totally stupid.


Has your Intellegence Dept or Wise Board of Advisors ever made a llst of DONATIONS or aid sent to victims, when there is a major disaster in the U.S.?

We have had some very recent major disasters with Hurricanes, earthquakes, flooding, fires, 9/11, etc. How much have these generous countries sent to out victims? Do they really have room to whine, or is it just the liberals and their Press, that make derogeratory remarks?


Donations and aid are a voluntary act of charity, but are being expected as mandatory from the U.S.


We have come to the aid of the Europeans (France, Germany, as an example) numerous times in cases of Wars and natural diasters.

Even the war in Yugoslavia couldn't be handled without our help. Or how about the countries in Africa, where they have closer connections.


Apparently, the amount of money we are spending in the Middle East doesn't count in their minds.


There is a time to stop feeling guilty and manipulated by the press and 24/7 TV networks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

In order to post in the Political Issues forum, all members are required to acknowledge that their post is in compliance with our Community Guidelines.  In addition, you acknowledge that it meets the following requirements: 

  • No personal attacks: Attack the issue not the person
  • No hijacking: Stay on the subject of the thread 

  • No bullying, hate speech or offensive terms/expressions

In addition, if the moderators feel someone is reporting content simply because if it’s political stance (such as but not limited to reporting it as off topic but not other off topic replies by those that agree with your stance), the reporting person may receive a warning as well.

Content that does not comply with the above requirements will be removed.  Multiple violations may result in a loss of access to this forum.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Create New...